Caturday Reads: Murder, break-ins and a sleuthing cat make Cat With a Clue a winning read
September 10, 2016
Caturday Reads: From Poodles to Thoroughbreds Live and Let Growl is a Winner
September 3, 2016
Caturday Reads: A loving portrayal of the older dogs who make our lives complete
September 17, 2016
Memorable but not meaningful graphic novel explores the essence of music
June 29, 2017
Comics and Graphic
Pub Date 30 May 2017
Why do you create? What is the purpose for art, for music? What would you give to be noticed, remembered? Tom is a man who is a good trumpet player, but not a great one. He is dissatisfied with playing with his friends, angry and more than a little self-centered. One day an old man gives him a black trumpet. With it, Tom is able to play music that captivates and inspires, but it also kills. In addition to the terrible price of playing, homeless cultists are pursuing Tom in order to retrieve the trumpet. While dodging their attempts, Tom travels between worlds, encountering musicians from bygone eras who argue the purpose of creation. The graphic novel is definitely strange. Between the cultists who worship these otherworldly instruments and the surreal encounters with those who created great music, it’s easy to understand why Tom becomes more and more paranoid. Instrumental is not the easiest graphic novel to follow or even like. The ending is particularly odd. I did like the concept behind the novel, and the pairing with the jazz soundtrack, but that doesn’t redeem Chisolm’s work. It is too incoherent to be meaningful, but I will grant that it is memorable
3 / 5
I received a copy of Instrumental from Diamond Books in exchange for an honest review.
Tom is an good trumpet player but not a great musician. One day after a set with his band at a local café, tom is given a black trumpet by an mysterious old man. Whenever the Trumpet is played otherworldly music comes out however it comes with a price that someone dies whenever it is played
Like a musical Faust Tom must decide if what the value of great art is all the while dodging deranged cultists and discovering the mysterious origins of the "instrument"
Includes a Jazz Soundtrack by the writer Dave Chisholm